J Nagarathna: in UP v Jai Bir Singh, 5 judges... ... 'Industry' Definition Judgment : Live Updates From Supreme Court 9-Judge Bench

J Nagarathna: in UP v Jai Bir Singh, 5 judges referred for reconsideration the 7 judge bench. i have said that it was not necessary. I have given 10 reasons why there was no reason to answer the reference. I have gone into history, and have analysed each opinion in Bangalore water supply judgment, overruling on Safardung judgment, why expansive definition of industry is necessary.

one can't lose sight of the precarious condition of india during independence, given the situation as it was, the privatisation and liberation was important for india, these were experiments to achieve constitutional goals. in this backdrop the judgment must be viewed.