J Bagchi: the text extended benefically to the... ... 'Industry' Definition Judgment : Live Updates From Supreme Court 9-Judge Bench

J Bagchi: the text extended benefically to the workmen, and didn't restrict to activities on commerical. the criticism is misplaced as it carves out just and proper exclusion on domestic activities, small and unorganised clubs etc. on public duties and welfare activities, I have held that the concept of sovereignty is restricted to inalienable duty where states are not answerable to courts but people. viewed from this prespective, mere vesting of duty doesn't clothe it within sovereign immunity.