academy Icon academy Icon lawbiz Icon
Subscribe Premium

Supreme Court Issues Notice To TN Govt On Plea To Remove Atheistic Inscriptions In Periyar Statues

Deepankar Malviya

13 Sept 2022 10:09 AM IST

    • Supreme Court Issues Notice To TN Govt On Plea To Remove Atheistic Inscriptions In Periyar Statues

    The Supreme Court on Monday issued notice and sought response from the Tamil Nadu Government and Dravidar Kazhagam on a plea seeking removal of atheistic inscriptions at the statue of Periyar erected all over the State of Tamil Nadu. A bench comprising Justices Sanjay Kishan Kaul and A S Oka issued notice on the petition which contended that the inscriptions hurt the belief and sentiments of...

    The Supreme Court on Monday issued notice and sought response from the Tamil Nadu Government and Dravidar Kazhagam on a plea seeking removal of atheistic inscriptions at the statue of Periyar erected all over the State of Tamil Nadu. 

    A bench comprising Justices Sanjay Kishan Kaul and A S Oka issued notice on the petition which contended that the inscriptions hurt the belief and sentiments of the petitioner and public at large.

    The plea filed by Dr. M. Deivanayagam challenged the judgment delivered by the High Court of Madras  in September 2019 dismissing his petition by holding that the Petitioner's right under Article 19 to express his views on religion are equivalent with the rights of the Respondent Dravidar Kazhagam to disagree with the views.

    "If the petitioner has a constitutional right under Article 19 of the Constitution of India, to express his views on religion and existence of God, in the light of the decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Lalai Singh Yadav's case, we are of the view that the 2nd respondent and the members of the party, or followers of Thanthai Periyar, in exercise of the rights under Article 19 of the Constitution of India, has a right to disagree with the same", the High Court in the judgment stated.
    The petitioner had in his petition pointed out the translated version of the inscription which stated that,
    "There is no God, no God, no God,
    Those who preached God is fool,
    Those who spread God is Rogue
    Those who pray Gods are barbarians"
    Referring to the order of dismissal of the High Court the petition pointed out that, "The Hon'ble High Court's reasons to deny the Petitioner relief are thus premised on the factual finding that 'Periyar' may have in fact supported atheism, without considering that such inscriptions, are not only gravely insulting the religious feelings of believers but also is violative of the constitutional guarantee to practice and propagate one's religion with dignity."
    The petition also stated that the High Court ought to have considered that, these statues with such inscriptions are ridiculing the God, the religion and the believer alike that are sanctioned by the State amounts to public vilification of religion and strikes at the essence of secularism which demands strict separation of State and religion.
    "By sanctioning such inscriptions, the State has not only alienated, but also discriminated against believers of God, and thereby, violated their right to equal treatment, and right to life with dignity under Article 14 and 21 of the Constitution. Further, State's sanction of such inscriptions is inconsistent with the constitutional guarantees of free thought and conscience, and right to profess and propagate one's religion under Article19, 25 and 26 of the Constitution", the petition added.
    It was contended that the contents of the inscription inscribed on the statue amounts to hate speech by the Dravidar Kazhagam, which under the guise of exercising fundamental right under Article 19(1)(a) of Constitution, is actually trying to spread menace in the society on religious grounds. It was added that, "the inscriptions tantamount to causing apprehension to the safety and security of people-of-faith in the State and is laying down groundwork for later attacks on other religious sects. Such hate speeches tend to reduce equal social standing of the people-of-faith and cause a direct affront to their dignity."
    The petition also stated that the State of Tamil Nadu has abdicated from its responsibility of protection of human dignity and has denigrated the dignity of people-of-faith by permitting the existence of such inscriptions on the statues of 'Periyar' across the State.
    Case Title : Dr. M. Deivanayagam vs Chief Secretary Govt of Tamil Nadu - Diary No 22422/2021


    Tags
    PeriyarAtheism#Justice Sanjay Kishan KaulJustice Abhay S. Oka
    Deepankar Malviya

    Deepankar Malviya

    LiveLaw Biz

    LiveLaw WhatsApp Channel
    Next Story
    X
    x
    IP subscription is detected for  
    Please register yourself for unlimited free access.
    Redirecting to register page...